Christmas Pie & Pastry Pre-Orders
UPDATE: We are sold out of our Christmas pre-orders at this time. We will be making as many *EXTRA* pies and pastries for same-day pickup on Tuesday 12/23 and Wednesday 12/24 if you would like to snag an extra pie or missed the pre-order period! We are open 8am-5pm on Tuesday and 8am-11am on Wednesday. Please COME EARLY or order online via our same-day menu starting at 8am both days if you'd like to snag an extra pie! Merry Christmas!!!
We are Open 8am-5pm on Tuesday 12/23, and 8am-11am on Wednesday 12/24 (pre-order pickup ends at 11am). We will be closed Christmas Day!
Please COME EARLY or order online via our same-day menu starting at 8am if you'd like to snag an extra pie! MERRY CHRISTMAS!!!
🎄Ho Ho Ho - It's that time of year once again! Please place your pre-orders for Christmas week pickup here.
Our holiday / Christmas pie menu this year includes:
- Chocolate Peppermint Pie ("Candy Cane Pie!") - Chocolate peppermint cream folded in our homemade chocolate sable cookie crust, topped with freshly whipped cream, crumbled cookies, and candy cane bits. Santa approves!! 🎅🏼
-
Caramel Apple Cider Pie - Heirloom variety apples, freshly ground spices, and our homemade caramel apple sauce are baked inside our all-butter pie crust and topped with a brown butter crumble. The perfect mix of sweet and tart! 🍎
- Heirloom Apple Pie - Over 2 pounds of heirloom variety apples lovingly baked into our signature all-butter double crust. A traditional apple pie that Chicago Tribune restaurant critic Phil Vettel called "A Work of Art!"
- Cranberry Dutch Custard Pie with Walnut Crumble - Fresh cranberries baked inside a rich & creamy dutch custard and topped with a crunchy, sweet, & crumbly walnut topping 🎄
-
Pumpkin Cheesecake with a Gingersnap Crust - Creamy pumpkin cheesecake with freshly ground spices, baked inside a gingersnap crumb shell and topped with crème fraîche whipped cream. Meg's favorite! ☃️
We also have cookies, pastries, bread, and other goodies available:
- Holiday Gingerbread Loaf (serves 6-8 per loaf)
- Banana Bread Loaf (serves 6-8 per loaf)
- Quiche Lorraine: Slagel Farms Ham, Melty Gruyere Cheese, Caramelized Onions, Grainy Dijon Mustard, & Chopped Fresh Herbs
- Vegetarian Quiche: Broccoli & Goat Cheese with Caramelized Onions & Fresh Herbs
- Bake-At-Home Buttermilk Biscuits (1/2 dozen pack)
- Fresh Vanilla Whip Cream (for topping pies, breads, coffee, or cocktails!)
- Spilt Milk Blend Coffee (1 lb. of beans)
Pickup is available on:
- Tuesday, December 23 from 8am-5pm
- Wednesday, December 24 from 8am-11am (Please note: shorter hours on Christmas Eve!!)
We are closed on Christmas Day.
STORAGE >>
Both types of Apple Pies should be stored in their boxes on the countertop. If it is very humid or warm in your house (above 70 degrees), store fruit pies in the fridge until the day of serving. Fruit pies can be gently warmed (covered with foil) in a 325 degree oven for 15-20 minutes if you'd like to serve them warm.
Cranberry Custard, Chocolate Peppermint, and Pumpkin Cheesecake pies contain dairy and do require refrigeration up until the time of serving!
OTHER INFO >>
If we are sold out of your preferred pie flavor / pickup date option, please know that we always make EXTRA pies and pastries that will be available for same-day pickup during Christmas week. We open at 8am each day - please stop by to shop!
The last day to change or cancel your Christmas order is Tuesday, December 16th. By placing an order, you consent to our refund, cancellation, & "forgotten order" policy. Click here to read the policy in full.
If you have any questions or need help, please don't hesitate to reach out via email to hello@spiltmilkpastry.com and someone from our team will get back to you 😍