How To Order

We accept same-day orders as well as advance pre-orders with a minimum of 2 days notice. Some products may require additional advance notice when ordering.

Same-Day Orders:

Same day ordering is available online (click here to order), in-store, or over the phone during business hours. We are open Monday thru Saturday from 8am-5pm and Sunday from 8am-3pm. 

For same-day online ordering: We post our menu each morning by about 7am. Online ordering is available starting at 8am when we open. The website will not allow you to place a same-day order outside of business hours 

We also accept walk-in orders at our shop in Oak Park, or you are welcome to order over the phone by calling us at (708) 613-4403. Please keep in mind we have a small team, and always prioritize serving in-person customers. If you get the voicemail when calling - please bear with us and try your call again later.

Advance Pre-Orders:

You are welcome to place an order in advance - in fact, we encourage it! We accept advance pre-orders for whole pies, trays of cookies and breakfast pastries, speciality breads, catered sandwiches, and more.

Please place advance orders online - click here to order online. If you'd like to order something you don't see listed on the website, please email us ( or call us at the shop - (708) 613-4403.

Note: we always require a minimum of 2 days advance notice for any pre-orders / special orders. Some items require additional advance notice. If you have any questions or need help ordering, please reach out and we're hapy to help.


If you have any questions about how to order, you are always welcome to email us at, or call the shop at (708) 613-4403 and someone will be happy to assist you!

Thank you for ordering from Spilt Milk!