Skip to content

This store requires javascript to be enabled for some features to work correctly.

  • Order Online
    • Order Online (Same Day Pickup)
      • Pie
      • Pastries
      • Cookies
      • Savory Breakfast
      • Lunch
      • Bread
      • Hot Beverages
      • Cold Beverages
      • Extras / Add Ons / Sides
    • Order Online (Future Dates)
  • Catering & Events
  • Gift Cards
  • Friday Night Dinner
  • Donation Requests
  • Log in
Spilt Milk Pastry
  • 0
  • Order Online
    • Order Online (Same Day Pickup)
      • Pie
      • Pastries
      • Cookies
      • Savory Breakfast
      • Lunch
      • Bread
      • Hot Beverages
      • Cold Beverages
      • Extras / Add Ons / Sides
    • Order Online (Future Dates)
  • Catering & Events
  • Gift Cards
  • Friday Night Dinner
  • Donation Requests
Spilt Milk Pastry
0 Cart

Same Day Orderes

The items below can be ordered online for pickup at our shop in Oak Park, IL. Please note that Same Day orders can ONLY be placed during business hours - the system will not allow you to place a same-day order when the shop is closed!

We open online orders every day at 8am when the shop opens.

To place an order for a future date, please click here!

Yogurt Parfait
Regular price $7.50
$7.50
Coconut Chia Pudding Parfait
Regular price $9.00
$9.00
Great Lakes Potato Chips
Regular price $1.99
$1.99
Garden Goddess Sandwich
Regular price $12.00
$12.00
Ham, Butter & Gruyere Sandwich
Regular price $12.75
$12.75
Sold out
Waldorf Chicken Salad Croissant Sandwiches
Regular price $7.00
$7.00
Chicken Salad Pint
Regular price $14.00
$14.00
Side of Seasonally Rotating Jam
Regular price $0.50
$0.50
Side of Butter
Regular price $0.50
$0.50
Natalie's Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice (16oz Bottle)
Regular price $4.29
$4.29
Sold out
Spilt Milk "Kitchen Sink" Cookie
Regular price $4.00
$4.00
Take & Bake Chocolate Chip Cookies
Regular price $26.00
$26.00
Frozen Buttermilk Biscuits
Regular price $26.00
$26.00
Frozen Soup (Quart)
From Regular price $18.00
From $18.00
Sold out
Peach Danish
Regular price $6.75
$6.75
Bake at Home All-Butter Pie Shell
Regular price $7.50
$7.50
Sold out
Frozen Cherry Crumble Cake
Regular price $24.00
$24.00
Frozen Double Chocolate Brownies
Regular price $36.00
$36.00
Sold out
Peach Pie with Crumble topping
From Regular price $9.00
From $9.00
Dark Matter Coffee Beans - 12 oz
Regular price $21.00
$21.00
Gluten Free & Flourless Monster Cookie
Regular price $3.75
$3.75
Strawberry Horchata Matcha
From Regular price $6.00
From $6.00
Banana Matcha
From Regular price $6.00
From $6.00
Sparkling Passionfruit Coconut Lemonade
From Regular price $5.50
From $5.50
Sold out
Toffee Crunch Cheesecake
From Regular price $7.75
From $7.75
Sold out
Berry Pop-Tart
Regular price $3.75
$3.75
Sold out
Spilt Milk Energy Bites
Regular price $8.00
$8.00
Cookie Dough bites
Regular price $8.00
$8.00
Sold out
Blueberry Cheesecake Bar
Regular price $5.00
$5.00
Sold out
Bacon & Cheddar Biscuit
Regular price $5.50
$5.50
cherry Crumble Cake Bar
Regular price $5.00
$5.00
Sold out
Peach Cobbler Cookie
Regular price $5.00
$5.00
Sold out
Rhubarb Orange Muffin
Regular price $4.85
$4.85
Raspberry Lemon Loaf
From Regular price $5.10
From $5.10
Chocolate Nutella mousse Cup
Regular price $8.00
$8.00
Load more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
Quick Links
  • Contact & FAQ
  • Newsletter Signup
  • Cancellation, Refund, & "Forgotten Order" Policies
  • Privacy Policy
Contact Us

Call: (708) 613-4403

General Inquires: hello@spiltmilkpastry.com

Manager's Email: Kayla@spiltmilkpastry.com

Operating Hours

Monday thru Saturday: 8am-5pm

Sunday: 8am-2pm

To confirm holiday hours + any special closures, please check our Instagram page or call the store.

  • © 2026, Spilt Milk Pastry
  • Powered by Shopify
  • © 2026, Spilt Milk Pastry
  • Powered by Shopify