Valentine's Day Pre-Orders 2026

Valentine's Day is Saturday, February 14th ... don't forget to order some treats for your sweetie! Pickup for all Valentine's Day pre-orders will be on Saturdayday, February 14th from 8am-5pm. If you'd like to place an order for a different day, please call the shop at (708) 613-4403 or order online from our regular pre-order menu (linked here).

➡️ NOTE: 9" pies are our "regular" size and serve 6-8 people. 6" pies are our "mini" size and serve 2-3 people.

Our Valentine's Day menu this year includes:

• 🍓🍫 Strawberry Chocolate Cream Pie: Our classic chocolate cream pie with a Valentine's twist! Topped with Strawberry-kissed whip cream, cookie crumbles, & Valentine-themed sprinkles (Available in regular and mini size!)

• ❤️🔥 Blackberry Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake: Vanilla cheesecake laced with raspberry/blackberry jam and topped with a cloud of whip cream. (Available in regular and mini size!)

• 🍒🌰Black Forest Cherry Almond Pie: A layer of dark chocolate ganache topped with local Michigan sweet cherry compote with almond liquor, dark chocolate mousse, candied almonds, fresh whipped cream, chocolate shavings, and fresh cherries... all inside our signature all-butter pie crust.

• 🍒 Tart Cherry Pie: Michigan tart cherries from our friends at Ellis Family Farms are lovingly baked inside our signature hand-rolled, all-butter double pie crust - a classic pie that's perfect for sharing with the ones you love!

• ♥️Chocolate Chess:  Our chocolate chess pie is a sweeter take on the original, we sometimes call this our "brownie pie"! When the pie bakes, it puffs up almost like a soufflé, and then as it cools ... it falls, creating a crinkly, crunchy top layer which we dust with powdered sugar. (Available in regular and mini size!)

• 🍫 Chocolate Truffle Pound Cake: A chocolate-lovers dream! Our dark chocolate sour cream pound cake is truly perfection, topped with a rich, chocolate ganache frosting, cocoa nibs, chocolate crispies, and a sprinkle of sea salt ... you do NOT want to miss this delicious Spilt Milk classic! (6-8 servings per loaf)

• 🍓 Cupcakes & Chocolate-Covered Strawberries: Perfect for gifting or enjoying with loved ones! Each box includes 3 dark chocolate cupcakes with chocolate buttercream icing and 3 chocolate covered strawberries (half-dozen treats per box total)

• 🎨 DIY Cookie Decorating Kit: All the supplies you need to have a cookie decorating party with your Valentines! Each kit includes six heart-shaped sugar cookie cutouts, plus buttercream frosting in a piping bag & Valentine-themed sprinkles.
  

Please pick up your order any time between 8am-5pm on Saturday, February 14 2026!