Mother's Day Pre-Orders

We are sold out of pre-orders at this time. If you missed the pre-order period, please order with us same-day on Saturday and Sunday! We will be baking as many extra pies and pastries as we can. Online ordering starts at 8am on Saturday and Sunday, or please come by the bakery to shop with us in person. Happy Mother's Day!

Happy Mother's Day! Celebrate the momma or mom figure in your life with a special treat from Spilt Milk.

Mother's Day pre-order pickups are for Sunday, May 8th from 8am-3pm.

Our Mother's Day menu this year includes:

  • Quiche (meat option): Slagel Ham with Peppers & Onions, and Emmental cheese
  • Quiche (veggie option): Asparagus, chef's mix of mushrooms from River Valley Ranch farms, caramelized onions, & chevre cheese (goat cheese)
  • Raspberry Lemonade Pie
  • Apple Blueberry Rhubarb Pie (it's baaaaack - voted "Best Pie In Chicago" by Chicago Magazine!)
  • Passionfruit Cheesecake Pie
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Chess Pie
  • Key Lime Pie
  • Chocolate Cream Pie
  • Vanilla Chocolate Swirl Pound Cake
  • Cookie Box: a treasure chest of delicious cookies for mom!! Each box includes approximately 20 cookies and is a mix of polvorones, decorated sugar cookies, sage brown butter shortbread, linzer thumbprints with raspberry jam, triple chocolate cookies, and lemon poppyseed pinwheels. Cookie box contains nuts.

Quiche, 9" pies, and pound cake serve approximately 6-8 people. 6" pies serve 1-2 people. 

  • $41.00
- 0%