Thanksgiving Pre-Orders

Thanksgiving Pre-Orders

from 8.00

You know what goes great with turkey, stuffing, and green beans? PIE ... and lots of it!! Whether you are celebrating with family, friends, or neighbors...we would love to be a part of your Thanksgiving celebration :-)

We are now accepting pre-orders for Thanksgiving! Our menu this year includes traditional pumpkin pie, pumpkin pecan praline pie, our classic heirloom apple pie, bourbon maple pecan with dark chocolate pie, and chocolate hazelnut chess pie ... YUM!

You can also add on fresh whipped Kilgus cream or pumpkin bread (1/2 loaf minimum) to your Thanksgiving order.

Pickup will be on Monday, November 20th, Tuesday, November 21st, or Wednesday, November 22nd. We are closed on Thanksgiving Day. Our hours for these three days will be:

Monday: 4pm - 6pm (pre-order pickups walk-ins)

Tuesday: 7am - 6pm

Wednesday: 6am - 6pm


After you add your items to the cart, scroll to the top of the page and click the shopping cart icon in the upper right-hand corner to place your order!

Pie Flavor:
Add to Order

You will select your pickup date when placing your order. Your order MUST be picked up on the date you indicate when placing your order! If you don't pick up your pie on the day indicated on your order form, it will be donated to the food bank. Sorry, we are not able to issue refunds for no-shows.

If you need to change or cancel your order, we need 72 hours notice PRIOR to your pickup date. Please call (708) 613-4403 to change/cancel your order. We do not accept changes or cancellations over email, Facebook messenger, social media comments, etc. Please call the shop if you have to make changes to your order and ask for Meg or Adrian!

Happy Thanksgiving!!!