Catering Menu_Spilt Milk Pastry

You may also place a catering order by calling our catering office at (708) 669-8881.

Spilt Milk Breakfast Catering

All breakfast trays are available in Small (serves 10),
Medium (serves 20), or Large (serves 30) sizes.

Breakfast at Spilt Milk

Assortment of freshly baked,
homemade scones, muffins,
biscuits, and banana bread
or almond tea cake
$50 | $95 | $130

Breakfast at Spilt Milk

British Breakfast

Slices of our homemade
all-butter coffee cake
& freshly baked scones.
Served with whipped
European-style butter
and locally-made
Rare Bird Preserves.
Add clotted cream for an additional $8
$65 | $120 | $170

Just Biscuits

Mini versions of our
world-famous, homemade
buttermilk biscuits!
Served with whipped
European-style butter,
locally-made Rare Bird Preserves,
and Michigan wildflower honey.
$40 | $75 | $105

Homemade Coffee Cake

Homemade, all-butter coffee cake
available in three flavors:
citrus, cinnamon & sugar,
and mixed berry.
Choose from small (serves 6)
or large (10-12).
Can be pre-sliced and plated for an
additional $5 per cake

$30 | $45


We make our quiches in a hand-rolled, all-butter pastry crust, and fill with local eggs and cream from Kilgus dairy in Marengo, IL.

Trays of mini quiche are available in Small (serves 10), Medium (serves 20), and Large (serves 30) sizes.

Full-sized quiche serve 6-8 people, and are priced at $30 per pie.


Vegetarian Quiche Options


Caprese Quiche

Tomato, Basil, and Whole-Milk Mozzarella cheese

Garden Quiche

Mushrooms, Spinach, Bell Pepper, Tomato, and Sharp Cheddar Cheese

$45 | $80 | $115

Meat Quiche Options


Quiche Lorraine

Emmentaler cheese, Pancetta, and Sweet Onions

South of the Border

Carnivore Chorizo, Queso Fresco, Green Peppers

$50 | $85 | $120

a la carte breakfast

a la carte selections available in Small (serves 10),
Medium (serves 20), or Large (serves 30) trays.

Scrambled Eggs

$35 | $65 | $95

Bacon or Sausage

$40 | $70 | $105

Seasonal Fruit Salad

$45 | $85 | $125

Dessert & Pastry Trays from Spilt Milk
Cookie Trays from Spilt Milk

Cookie Trays

Cookie trays available in Small (20 pieces),
Medium (46 pieces), or Large (70 pieces).

"Cookie Monster"
Assortment of our classic cookie flavors. Selection may vary by season & availability

"Chocolate Lover Cookie Tray"
Assortment of Mexican Chocolate, Chocolate Chip, and Rainbow M&M Cookies

"Spilt Milk Classics"
Includes Brown Butter Sugar, Mexican Chocolate, and Chocolate Chip Cookies

"Choose Your Own"

"Kiddos Favorites"
Includes Rainbow Sprinkle & Rainbow M&M cookies

"Brownie Tray"
A heaping tray of our classic, fudgy brownies!

“The Kitchen Sink”
A little bit of everything! All our favorite cookies, plus
brownies and seasonal fruit bars

$45 | $85 | $125

Hand Pies

Our hand pies are filled with homemade sweet or savory fillings and lovingly wrapped in a flaky cream cheese pastry crust. Hand pie trays include a selection of our "mini" 3-bite hand pies and are available in small (serves 10), medium (serves 20), or large (serves 30) tray sizes.

Sweet Hand Pies

Fruit fillings selections vary by season, and may include:

  • Cherry Berry (tart cherries, strawberries, blueberries, and/or raspberries)

  • Mixed Stone Fruit (cherries, nectarines, peaches, and/or plums)

  • Mixed Berry (strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, and/or mulberries)

  • Chocolate Banana

  • Heirloom Apple

Savory Hand Pies

  • Potato, Cheddar, & Herb (purple potato available seasonally!)

  • Spinach Artichoke

  • Squash & Goat Cheese

  • Buffalo Chicken

  • Chicken Mole with Roasted Veggies

  • Pulled BBQ Pork

  • Pizza (Italian sausage, homemade marinara, veggies, & mozzarella)

Vegetarian & Sweet:

$30 | $55 | $80


$35 | $60 | $85


Mini Pies
Miniature versions of our seasonal fruit pies, with crumb topping...available with or without nuts.

Whole Pies
We offer two sizes:
6” pies serve 2-3 people
9” pies serve 6-8 people

Pie flavors vary by season. Not all of our pie flavors can be made in all sizes. Please contact our catering manager for a full list of our current pie flavors!

Spilt Milk Pies

You may also place a catering order by calling our catering office at (708) 669-8881.